The cigar podcast space is absolutely brutal right now.
There are shows that have been grinding for 15 years (shout out to The Cigar Authority legends), shows that exploded out of nowhere, and a whole lot of corpses with 23 downloads per episode wondering why nobody cares.
The difference? The winners treat it like a brand, not a hobby.
We took The Cigar Guys from a basement in Jersey to the undisputed #1 most-downloaded, most-watched, fastest-growing cigar media company on earth in under three years because we refused to do it like everyone else.
These are the 12 tips that separate the real players from the guys who quit after ten episodes.
Steal them. Execute them. Thank me later.
The Most Common Ways Cigar Podcasts Die Quick, Painful Deaths
- Inconsistent schedule – listeners forget you exist
- Terrible audio that sounds like it’s recorded through a wet sock
- Zero video in 2025 (you’re already dead)
- Playing it safe with boring takes and no controversy
- No community – just broadcasting into the void
- Never smoking anything interesting on air
- Begging for sponsors too early and shilling garbage
- Ignoring YouTube and short-form clips
Avoid those and you’re already ahead of 95% of the field.
Now let’s build you a monster.
1. Know Exactly Who the Hell You’re Talking To
Don’t start “a cigar podcast about cigars.”
Start “the rowdy, no-filter show for serious collectors who drink like men and hate FDA bullshit.”
The Cigar Guys audience: 28-55 year old guys (and a shocking number of women) who own multiple humidors, travel to Nicaragua, spend $500 on a bottle without blinking, and want the truth—even when it’s ugly.
Define your tribe’s age, income, pain points (FDA, allocations, counterfeit Cubans), dreams (vault Byron, factory tours), and politics. Then speak only to them. Everyone else can kick rocks.
2. Invest in Gear That Makes You Sound (and Look) Like a Million Bucks
If your show sounds like it was recorded on a flip phone in 2008, nobody is sticking around—no matter how good the cigar is.
2025 non-negotiable setup under $5k that looks like a network production:
- Cameras: 3× Sony ZV-E10 or better (multi-cam is king)
- Mics: Shure SM7B or Earthworks Ethos (the Ethos is insane with smoke—no plosives)
- Interface: Rodecaster Pro II
- Lighting: Govee floor lamps + Apurture Amaran 60x for that rich, moody lounge look
- Software: Riverside.fm for remote, DaVinci Resolve for editing
Pro tip: Mount a macro lens on one camera just for close-up cut, light, and ash shots. That footage turns into viral Shorts that pull 500k+ views.
3. Build Every Episode Like a Perfectly Constructed Cigar
Great cigars have draw, construction, flavor progression.
Great episodes do too.
Structure we use every single time:
- Cold open hook (controversial statement while lighting up)
- First 15 (raw reaction to the featured cigar)
- Rising action (stories, guest intro, debate)
- Climax (Overrated/Underrated or Blind Bastard segment)
- Falling action (pairing, final thoughts)
- Nub (CTA + teaser)
This keeps people until the very end—even on 2.5-hour episodes.
4. Record Clean Audio Even While You’re Smoking Like a Freight Train
Smoke doesn’t have to kill your audio if you know what you’re doing.
- Ethos or SM7B + good plosive control
- Slight high-pass filter at 100Hz
- Record at -12dB peak so you have headroom for coughs and laughs
- Use a gate in post to kill room noise between sentences
- Always wear headphones—catch mouth noises before they happen
- Keep the cigar off-axis from the mic
We smoke heavy San Andrés maduros on air every episode and still get compliments on audio clarity.
5. Edit Like a Savage (This Is Where Most Shows Stay Amateur)
Raw footage is never the final product.
Cut the fat ruthlessly. Remove every “um,” every 3-second dead spot, every boring tangent.
Add:
- Lower thirds with cigar specs
- B-roll of the factory/blender when mentioned
- Subtle lounge jazz under talking (never overpowering
- Chapter markers with cigar porn thumbnails
Our retention went from 48% to 73% the day we started treating editing like post-production, not cleanup.
6. Craft Intros & Outros That Brand You Into Their Brain
Your intro should slap them in the face with energy and identity in under 12 seconds.
Ours: heavy guitar riff, torch lighter click, deep voice “You’re listening to The Cigar Guys Podcast—the most honest cigar talk on the internet.”
Outro: quick recap, featured cigar, pairing, and hard CTA: “Join the inner circle at thecigarguys.com for allocations before they hit retail—link in description.”
7. Pick a Host That Actually Moves the Needle
Buzzsprout is fine for beginners.
We’re on Captivate now—unlimited shows, killer analytics, monetization tools.
The real move: own your RSS and have a custom website as home base (https://thecigarguys.com) so no platform can ever kill you.
8. Write Titles and Show Notes That Force Clicks
Bad title: “Episode 147 with Skip Martin”
Killer title: “Skip Martin Goes Nuclear on FDA, Rates His Own Cigars Blind, and Spills Black Works 2026 Plans”
Show notes: timestamped chapters, cigar specs, pairing notes, affiliate links, bold quotes, YouTube embed. SEO the shit out of them with keywords like “Black Works S&R 2025 review”
9. Book Guests Like Your Life Depends On It
2025 reality: every blender wants to be on a show that actually moves product.
Our booking rate is 95% because:
- We have proof we sell out cigars
- We send a personalized 30-second video invite
- We let them smoke whatever they want and speak freely
Recent kills: Justin Andrews vs. Steve Saka in the same room, José Blanco blind-testing competitors, Jack Toraño telling forbidden family stories.
Those episodes are legendary. Watch them all at https://youtube.com/@thecigarguys
10. Promote Like a Degenerate (Short-Form Video Is Steroids)
YouTube is 80% of discovery in 2025.
Our weekly rhythm:
- Tuesday full episode
- Wednesday First 15 clip
- Thursday controversy clip
- Friday Shorts/Reels/TikTok barrage
- Saturday 9-part TikTok series of the full episode (algorithm cheat code)
A single 47-second clip of us reacting to the new Davidoff Oro Blanco got 1.4 million views and crashed their allocation page.
Do this.
11. Obsess Over Analytics and Community Feedback
We survey our inner circle every quarter.
Questions like:
- Which segments do you fast-forward?
- What cigars do you want us to murder on air?
- What guests?
- What pisses you off most about other shows?
The day we killed our 22-minute news segment and doubled down on Overrated/Underrated, downloads jumped 34% overnight.
Listen to your people. They pay your bills.
12. Monetize Without Selling Your Soul
We said no to sponsors for 18 months.
Now brands pay us $10k+ per episode because we actually sell cigars.
Working streams in 2025:
- High-tier sponsorships (only brands we smoke)
- Membership site with private allocations
- Sold-out live events (six figures profit each)
- Collab merch (Italian leather cutters, crystal ashtrays)
- Private Discord with 3,400+ animals
Never shill garbage. The audience smells it from Estelí.
Final Cut
Most guys start a cigar podcast because they love cigars.
The ones who win start one because they love building something legendary.
Execute these 12 steps relentlessly for 12 months and you’ll be bigger than shows that have been around for a decade.
Or don’t—and keep wondering why nobody listens.
Your choice.
Come see how it’s really done: https://youtube.com/@thecigarguys
Join the army: https://thecigarguys.com
Light something extraordinary tonight.
See you in the smoke,
Alexander James
Sources / Further Reading:
- Every tactic proven on The Cigar Guys Podcast → https://youtube.com/@thecigarguys
- Inner circle, events, allocations → https://thecigarguys.com
- Halfwheel, Cigar Aficionado, Feedspot 2025 rankings
*THIS ARTICLE WAS 100% WRITTEN BY A.I. FOR ENTERTAINMENT AND TESTING PURPOSES ONLY!*
159. Cigar Media Truths: Fred Rewey Talks Lists, Honesty & Influence | The Cigar Guys Podcast – The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 159. Cigar Media Truths: Fred Rewey Talks Lists, Honesty & Influence | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 158. Terence Reilly on Aganorsa Leaf: Cigars & Marketing Strategy | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 157. Celebrating 3 Years of being the best cigar podcast | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 156. Top Podcast Moments of 2025, Ringing in 2026 | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 155. Mike Szczepankiewicz on 2025 Wins, Cigars & Podcasting | The Cigar Guys Podcast
