The cigar industry prides itself on tradition, craftsmanship, and heritage. These values are often cited as the foundation of cigar culture and the reason cigars continue to hold relevance in a fast-moving, disposable world. However, there is a growing issue within the cigar community that threatens its long-term survival: gatekeeping.
Gatekeeping in the cigar industry is rarely intentional or openly hostile. Instead, it appears through subtle behaviors, unspoken rules, and cultural norms that create unnecessary barriers for new cigar smokers. While often framed as preserving standards or protecting tradition, gatekeeping ultimately limits growth, discourages curiosity, and alienates the very people the industry needs to thrive.
If the cigar industry wants a future, it must confront this problem honestly.
What Gatekeeping Looks Like in Cigar Culture
Gatekeeping does not always present itself as outright exclusion. More often, it takes the form of judgment and hierarchy disguised as expertise.
Common behaviors include dismissing certain cigars as “not real,” equating quality exclusively with price, correcting preferences rather than understanding them, or framing cigar enjoyment as something that must be earned rather than explored. New smokers are frequently made to feel that their choices are inferior or that they lack sufficient knowledge to participate meaningfully in cigar conversations.
These attitudes create an environment where curiosity is replaced by hesitation. Instead of learning, experimenting, and developing a personal palate, new cigar smokers feel pressured to conform to narrow definitions of what is considered acceptable or respectable.
Over time, many simply disengage.
Why Gatekeeping Is Often Defended as Tradition
Those who engage in gatekeeping rarely believe they are harming the industry. In fact, many believe the opposite. The argument is often that standards must be upheld, that cigars deserve respect, and that the culture should not be diluted by trends or casual participation.
There is truth in the desire to preserve craftsmanship and knowledge. Cigars are complex products shaped by agriculture, fermentation, blending, and aging. Understanding those elements does enrich the experience.
The problem arises when education turns into exclusion.
Tradition should provide a foundation, not a barrier. When appreciation becomes arrogance, and expertise becomes a tool for validation rather than sharing, tradition stops serving the culture and starts suffocating it.
An industry that depends on rituals but refuses adaptation will inevitably shrink.
The Impact on New Cigar Smokers
The cigar industry often struggles to attract and retain new smokers, particularly younger adults. While regulations, pricing, and lifestyle changes all play a role, cultural resistance within the community itself is an underexamined factor.
New cigar smokers are not discouraged because cigars are difficult to understand. They are discouraged because the environment surrounding cigars can feel unwelcoming, overly judgmental, or inaccessible. When preferences are constantly questioned or corrected, enjoyment becomes stress rather than pleasure.
Cigar culture should invite exploration. Instead, gatekeeping signals that enjoyment is conditional.
This dynamic directly affects cigar lounges, events, media platforms, and brands that rely on expanding audiences. Without new participants who feel comfortable and respected, the community stagnates and slowly contracts.
The Business Cost of Gatekeeping
Beyond cultural concerns, gatekeeping has measurable economic consequences.
Cigar lounges depend on regular foot traffic, not just long-time patrons. Brands depend on new consumers discovering their products. Media platforms depend on growing audiences, not echo chambers. When new cigar smokers feel unwelcome, these ecosystems weaken.
An industry cannot survive by circulating the same conversations among the same people. Growth requires openness, education, and adaptability. Gatekeeping undermines all three.
As consumer behavior evolves and attention spans shorten, cigars already face significant competition from other leisure activities. Creating additional barriers only accelerates decline.
What a Healthy Cigar Culture Looks Like
A healthy cigar culture prioritizes education over intimidation and curiosity over correction. It recognizes that cigar enjoyment is subjective and that personal preference is not a flaw to be fixed.
In a sustainable cigar culture, questions are encouraged rather than dismissed. Preferences are discussed rather than ranked. Knowledge is shared generously, without the need to establish superiority.
This approach does not lower standards; it strengthens them. When people feel welcomed, they are more likely to learn, invest, and deepen their appreciation over time. Long-term enthusiasts are created through inclusion, not pressure.
Preserving Tradition Without Excluding the Future
Tradition and progress are not opposites. The most resilient cultures evolve while honoring their foundations. Cigars can remain rooted in history while adapting to new audiences, new tastes, and new ways of engaging.
Preserving tradition means passing it on, not guarding it.
The next generation of cigar smokers does not need permission to enjoy cigars. They need access, education, and respect. Without those, tradition becomes static, and static traditions fade.
A Clear Position on the Future of Cigars
The future of the cigar industry depends on its ability to welcome rather than judge, to educate rather than intimidate, and to invite participation rather than demand credentials.
Cigars are meant to bring people together through conversation, relaxation, and shared appreciation. Any behavior that turns them into tools of exclusion works against the very spirit that made cigar culture meaningful in the first place.
If the cigar industry wants longevity, it must replace gatekeeping with openness. Anything less risks losing the next generation entirely.
157. Celebrating 3 Years of being the best cigar podcast | The Cigar Guys Podcast – The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 157. Celebrating 3 Years of being the best cigar podcast | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 156. Top Podcast Moments of 2025, Ringing in 2026 | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 155. Mike Szczepankiewicz on 2025 Wins, Cigars & Podcasting | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 154. Holiday Cigars, Santa & Conspiracies (Christmas Special 2025) | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 153. I Forgot What This Episode Was About | The Cigar Guys Podcast
