When it comes to premium cigars, few industries are surrounded by as much mystique and misinformation. From how cigars should be stored to what makes one “premium,” cigar myths have circulated for decades. If you’re new to cigars—or even a seasoned aficionado—you’ve likely heard some of these misconceptions. Let’s set the record straight and debunk the most common cigar myths.
Myth 1: All Dark Cigars Are Strong
A popular belief is that darker cigars (maduro wrappers) are automatically stronger. In reality, wrapper color alone doesn’t determine strength. The strength of a cigar comes from the blend of tobaccos used in the filler and binder. Some dark cigars are smooth and mild, while some lighter ones can be bold and full-bodied.
👉 Truth: Don’t judge a cigar’s strength by its wrapper. Instead, ask about its flavor profile or try it yourself.
Myth 2: Premium Cigars Should Be Cut Far Down the Cap
Many beginners think cutting a large portion of the cap makes a better draw. Unfortunately, this often ruins the cigar by unraveling the wrapper.
👉 Truth: Always make a small, clean cut—just enough to create an open draw while keeping the cap intact.
Myth 3: Premium Cigars Should Be Inhaled Like Cigarettes
Cigars are not meant to be inhaled. Unlike cigarettes, cigars are enjoyed by savoring the flavor and aroma in your mouth. Inhaling cigar smoke can be harsh and unpleasant.
👉 Truth: Premium cigars are designed for tasting, not inhaling. Let the smoke linger in your mouth before gently exhaling.
Myth 4: Expensive Cigars Are Always Better
Price does not guarantee satisfaction. While some premium cigars cost more due to rarity or craftsmanship, many affordable cigars provide excellent quality and flavor.
👉 Truth: The best cigar is the one you enjoy most, regardless of price.
Myth 5: You Should Ash Your Cigar Frequently
Contrary to popular belief, constantly tapping the ash isn’t necessary. A solid ash acts as insulation, keeping the cigar cooler and burning evenly.
👉 Truth: Let the ash fall naturally when it’s ready—usually around one to two inches.
Myth 6: Cigars Should Be Stored in the Freezer
Some people think freezing cigars keeps them fresh. Freezing actually damages the delicate tobacco leaves.
👉 Truth: Premium cigars should be stored in a properly seasoned humidor at around 65–70% humidity and 68–70°F.
Myth 7: All Premium Cigars Come from Cuba
While Cuba has a legendary reputation, exceptional premium cigars are produced in the Dominican Republic, Nicaragua, Honduras, and other regions. Many aficionados even prefer these non-Cuban cigars for their complexity and variety.
👉 Truth: Great cigars come from multiple countries, each with unique terroir and traditions.
Final Thoughts
Understanding the truth about premium cigars enhances the smoking experience and helps you choose cigars with confidence. Whether you’re exploring different regions, wrappers, or strengths, remember that cigar enjoyment is highly personal. Don’t let myths guide your choices—let your palate decide.
171. Catelli Cigars Owners: Building a Brand & Lounge from Scratch | The Cigar Guys Podcast – The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 171. Catelli Cigars Owners: Building a Brand & Lounge from Scratch | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 170. PCA 2026 Preview: Sans Pareil CEO & VP on What’s Coming | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 169. Can We Guess These Whiskeys? Blind Barrels Challenge | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 168. What to Expect at PCA 2026 – William Marante Joins Us | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 167. Joe Perkins on Sans Pareil Cigars & His Career Journey | The Cigar Guys Podcast
