Top 10 Best Selling Cigar Brands (Valid or Not?)

In a recent episode of The Cigar Guys Podcast, hosts Alex, Mark, Jared, and Zach discuss the top 10 best-selling cigar brands. The hosts share their opinions on whether these brands deserve the recognition they receive and if their popularity is justified. Join them as they delve into the cigar world, discuss their favorites, and share their insights on some of the most popular cigar brands.

The episode starts with the hosts discussing their experiences with cigars and what they are smoking for the day. From the Bolivar to the Montecristo 1935 Anniversary Edition, each host shares their thoughts on the cigar they are currently enjoying.

The discussion then shifts to the main topic: the top 10 best-selling cigar brands. The first brand on the list is Arturo Fuente, known for its Hemingway and Opus X cigars. The hosts agree that Arturo Fuente is an underrated brand, offering high-quality cigars at a reasonable price. The cigars’ consistency and variety make them a favorite among the hosts.

Next on the list is Ashton, a brand that surprises some of the hosts due to its reputation as a boutique cigar. Despite this, the group agrees that Ashton deserves its place on the list, offering a consistently good smoking experience. However, the hosts also note that other brands have better flavor profiles and construction quality.

The conversation moves on to the third brand on the list, Oliva. The hosts consider Oliva to be a semi-valid entry, with some great cigars in their V series but lacking in other areas. They discuss how the brand targets a specific market and does a great job of marketing their products, but the overall quality may not be up to par with some of the other brands on the list.

Davidoff is the next brand up for discussion, and the hosts have mixed opinions on its place in the top 10. While some of the cigars in their lineup are highly regarded, such as the Davidoff Nicaragua, the hosts find that the brand’s reputation is somewhat overhyped. The high price point and the generally light body of Davidoff cigars make it difficult for the hosts to fully endorse the brand.

My Father is another brand on the list, known for its Le Bijou 1922 cigar. The hosts agree that My Father is a solid cigar brand, offering a good flavor profile at a reasonable price point. However, they also note that their personal preferences have shifted towards boutique cigar brands, which offer more interesting and unique experiences.

The discussion turns to Padron, a brand that has a special place in the hearts of the hosts. They agree that Padron is an underrated brand, offering consistently excellent cigars with a classic, elegant label. The hosts specifically mention the Padron Family Reserve and the 40-year anniversary edition as standout cigars in the lineup.

The final brand discussed is New World by A.J. Fernandez. The hosts have differing opinions on this brand, with some finding it underrated and others feeling that it is justifiably less popular than some of the other brands on the list. They discuss the brand’s price point and flavor profile, ultimately leaving the decision up to the individual smoker’s preferences.

Throughout the episode, the hosts also touch on other topics, such as the importance of supporting local cigar shops and the shift in their preferences towards boutique cigar brands. They share their experiences with various cigars, both good and bad, and discuss the role that marketing plays in the popularity of certain brands.


In conclusion, The Cigar Guys Podcast hosts have provided a comprehensive discussion on the top 10 best-selling cigar brands, offering their insights on the validity of each brand’s popularity. The conversation highlights the importance of personal preferences and individual smoking experiences in determining the actual value of a cigar brand. While some brands deserve their place on the list, others are seen as overhyped or better suited for a specific niche market.

As the podcast episode wraps up, the hosts emphasize that taste is subjective, and what works for one person may not work for another. They encourage listeners to explore various cigar brands, both popular and boutique, to find the perfect cigar for their palate. The hosts also stress the importance of supporting local businesses and enjoying cigars in a social setting, as the cigar community thrives on the shared experiences and camaraderie among enthusiasts.

In a world where marketing plays a significant role in shaping consumer preferences, it is essential to take the time to explore and appreciate the wide variety of cigar brands available. By doing so, you can make informed decisions about the cigars you choose to smoke and develop a deeper understanding of your personal tastes.

The Cigar Guys podcast episode offers valuable insights into the top 10 best-selling cigar brands, allowing both seasoned aficionados and those new to the world of cigars to make more informed choices when selecting their next smoke. Remember that the best cigar for you is the one you enjoy the most, regardless of its popularity or prestige.


Whether you are a long-time cigar enthusiast or just starting your journey into the world of cigars, this podcast episode is a must-listen for those seeking to expand their knowledge and appreciation of the diverse world of cigar brands. The hosts’ passion for cigars, combined with their informative and engaging discussion, makes for an enjoyable and enlightening experience.

So, light up your favorite cigar, sit back, and tune in to The Cigar Guys podcast as they explore the top 10 best-selling cigar brands and share their thoughts on the validity of each brand’s popularity. You might just discover your new favorite cigar brand or gain a new appreciation for a brand you’ve overlooked in the past.

Cigar Summary:

  1. Arturo Fuente: The group agrees that Arturo Fuente is a great brand with a wide variety of options, but they might be underrated due to people not trying their full range. They particularly enjoy the Hemingway and Opus X lines.
  2. Ashton: The group is surprised to see Ashton on the list, as it is often considered a boutique cigar. They believe Ashton deserves its spot on the list due to its consistent quality and the fact that they have never had a bad Ashton cigar.
  3. Oliva: They consider Oliva’s inclusion on the list to be semi-valid, as the brand is known for its high-quality V series. However, they think the brand as a whole is not as impressive.
  4. Macanudo: Macanudo is seen as a newbie smoke and not a standout cigar. Despite its popularity, the group does not believe it deserves a spot on the list.
  5. Rocky Patel: They consider Rocky Patel to be a popular brand, but they are not fans of the cigars themselves. They believe the brand is overhyped.
  6. Davidoff: While Davidoff is known for its elegant labels and reputation, the group believes it is overhyped. They think the Davidoff Nicaragua is worth trying but find the rest of the line to be too light-bodied for their tastes.
  7. My Father: The group appreciates the flavors offered by My Father cigars, but they are not fans of the busy label designs. They think the cigars are valid for inclusion on the list.
  8. Padron: The group is pleased to see Padron on the list and believe it is an underrated brand. They appreciate the classic, elegant labels and the consistent quality of the cigars.
  9. Alec Bradley: Alec Bradley is not discussed in detail, but they mention that it is a popular brand.
  10. Montecristo: The group enjoys the Montecristo 1935 Anniversary Edition and believe the brand deserves its spot on the list.

Throughout the discussion, the group also shares their experiences with various cigars and discusses the importance of label design and branding in the cigar industry. They acknowledge that their preferences lean more towards boutique cigars, which may influence their opinions on the mainstream brands listed. Ultimately, they believe that some of the best-selling cigar brands are valid, while others may be overhyped.

47. Validating Aganorsa Leaf | The Cigar Guys Podcast The Cigar Guys Podcast

The Cigar Guys are joined by Jeff and Fabian from Aganorsa Leaf cigars to discuss the company and showcase the process of tasting different tobacco leaves. Check out: Subscribe and turn on notifications so you don't miss an episode! Cigar Guys Merch: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Our Cigar Shop: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Our Cigar Book: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ Tip Jar: Collaboration/Sponsorship Inquiries: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Main Website: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ Follow us on social media:TikTok: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Twitter: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Instagram: ⁠⁠⁠ ⁠⁠Facebook: ⁠⁠⁠ ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Rumble: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ Co-Hosts:Alex: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Jared: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Mark: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Zach: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Featuring guest appearances of people that are involved in the cigar industry. #Cigars #CigarPodcast #CigarGuys #CigarShow #CigarReviews — Support this podcast:
  1. 47. Validating Aganorsa Leaf | The Cigar Guys Podcast
  2. 46. Thanksgiving Special 2023 | The Cigar Guys Podcast
  3. 45. Cigar Weddings with The Cigar Host | The Cigar Guys Podcast
  4. 44. La Aurora Cigars with William Marante | The Cigar Guys Podcast
  5. 43. Carlos Salvator (Pelican Humidors) | The Cigar Guys Podcast

Leave a Reply

Create a website or blog at