Cigar Aficionado employs a meticulous blind taste-test mechanism. The tasting coordinator de-identifies the cigars and replaces their bands with white, numbered labels. Consequently, the tasting panel remains unbiased, judging the cigars solely on their merit, regardless of price, origin, or brand.
Top-Rated Cigars:
- Arturo Fuente Hemingway Work of Art (95 points, $10.60): A familiar name on our elite list, the Hemingway line showcases perfectly crafted shapes constructed with a fine Cameroon wrapper over Dominican leaves. Its unique shape offers a flawless burn and draw, revealing flavors of chocolate, almond, and vanilla.
- Blackened Cigars “M81” by Drew Estate Corona (95 points, $9.15): A triumphant collaboration between Metallica’s James Hetfield, distiller Rob Dietrich, and Nicaraguan producer Drew Estate. This compact cigar packs a punch with tastes of saffron, baking spices, and a semi-sweet chocolate finish.
- Ashton Virgin Sun Grown Illusion (94 points, $14.15): Debuting in 1999, the VSG line was a robust entrant. Today, this Lonsdale still stands tall, offering a palate of rich earthiness combined with savory roasted peanut notes.
- E.P. Carrillo Pledge Sojourn (93 points, $13.25): An evolution of the 2020 Cigar of the Year, it boasts a Connecticut Habano cover leaf, an Ecuadoran binder, and Nicaraguan filler. Its robust flavors of earth and pepper harmoniously blend with nuances of leather and coffee, a testament to Ernesto Perez-Carrillo’s expertise.
- Padrón Family Reserve No. 44 Maduro (93 points, $34.85): Initially an exclusive, the Family Reserve line has expanded. Comprising of tobaccos aged for a decade, the No. 44 presents luxurious tastes of chocolate and espresso complemented by hints of oak and cedar.
- Tatuaje Miami Havana Cazadores (93 points, $12): Cigars produced in the U.S. are rare, but Pete Johnson of Tatuaje aims to preserve this tradition. Crafted in Miami’s El Rey de Los Habanos factory, it offers a stimulating blend of earth, black pepper, and coffee with undertones of chocolate and nutmeg.
159. Cigar Media Truths: Fred Rewey Talks Lists, Honesty & Influence | The Cigar Guys Podcast – The Cigar Guys Podcast
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/TheCigarGuysIn this episode of The Cigar Guys Podcast, we sit down with Fred Rewey from Cigar Press Magazine and host of the podcast Not A Cigar Show, for an honest and much-needed conversation about the state of cigar media today.This episode goes beyond the typical cigar show format as we critically examine top 25 cigar lists, media credibility, and the difficult balance between industry relationships and journalistic integrity.We discuss:• Whether top cigar lists still matter — and how they can mislead smokers• Can cigar media stay honest while maintaining industry relationships?• Are cigar journalists still journalists — or mostly hosts and entertainers now?• Should cigar media challenge brands and the industry more often?• The pressure, responsibility, and evolution of modern cigar coverageThis conversation is thoughtful, candid, and occasionally uncomfortable — exactly how meaningful cigar media discussions should be. If you care about transparency, credibility, and the future of cigar journalism, this episode delivers real insight.👉 LIKE, COMMENT & SUBSCRIBE for more in-depth cigar conversations, industry discussions, and cigar show–level debates that actually matter.🎙 The Cigar Guys PodcastHosts: Alex Gonzalez, Mark Nikollaj, Zachary Nikollaj, and Jared Burrows📲 Follow us on Instagram & TikTok: @thecigarguys🔥 Special thanks to Fred Rewey, Cigar Press Magazine, and Not A Cigar Show.——————————Sponsored by Sans Pareil Cigars: https://sanspareilcigar.com/Tip Jar: https://paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=G8A8MU7Y3V9W8Text or Call us: https://app.minnect.com/expert/TheCigarGuysCigar providers, accessories, and more content:https://thecigarguys.com/socialsOur Cigar Brand: https://1102cigars.comCigar Guys Merch: https://cigarguys.shopOur Cigar Book: https://amazon.com/Cigar-Guys-Ultimate-Guide-Smoking/dp/B0C7DXRCCRCollaboration/Sponsorship Inquiries: info@thecigarguys.comMain Website: https://thecigarguys.comFollow us on social media:TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@thecigarguysTwitter: https://twitter.com/thecigarguys Instagram: https://instagram.com/thecigarguysFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/realcigarguysFeaturing guest appearances of people that are involved in the cigar industry.#Cigars #CigarPodcast #CigarGuys #CigarShow #CigarReviews
- 159. Cigar Media Truths: Fred Rewey Talks Lists, Honesty & Influence | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 158. Terence Reilly on Aganorsa Leaf: Cigars & Marketing Strategy | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 157. Celebrating 3 Years of being the best cigar podcast | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 156. Top Podcast Moments of 2025, Ringing in 2026 | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 155. Mike Szczepankiewicz on 2025 Wins, Cigars & Podcasting | The Cigar Guys Podcast
