THE CIGAR GUYS
← ALL POSTS

J.C. Newman’s El Baton Belicoso Makes Cigar Aficionado’s ‘Extraordinary Smokes’ List

SHAREXf✉
J.C. Newman’s El Baton Belicoso Makes Cigar Aficionado’s ‘Extraordinary Smokes’ List

J.C. Newman Cigar Co. has a new reason to talk about one of its most affordable Nicaraguan cigars. Cigar Aficionado included the El Baton Belicoso on its list of “13 Extraordinary Smokes That Should Be In Your Humidor”, a roundup of high-scoring cigars from the magazine’s September/October 2026 issue. The Belicoso received 92 points.

The company shared the news in an email on Nov. 19, 2026, pointing readers to both the list and Cigar Aficionado’s full tasting note.

J.C. Newman El Baton Belicoso cigar
The J.C. Newman El Baton Belicoso, a 5-inch by 56-ring figurado. Photo: Cigar Aficionado

What the Magazine Tasted

The rated cigar is a 5″ x 56 figurado, priced at $10.40. Cigar Aficionado lists it as medium-full in strength, with an Ecuador wrapper and Nicaraguan binder and filler, made in Nicaragua. The tasting note is short and favorable:

“Although initial puffs are flinty and earthy, this dark torpedo warms to show the rich, sweet qualities of chocolate, nuts and toffee. The burn is even the entire time, as is the draw.”

Thomas Pappalardo, who wrote the Nov. 9 list for Cigar Aficionado, noted that more than half of the issue’s cigars scored 90 points or higher. The “extraordinary smokes” list is the upper tier of those blind tastings. The magazine says every cigar it rates is smoked blind, with the bands removed and replaced by plain numbered labels so the panel does not know the brand, price or country of origin.

An Old Name With a Newer Blend

El Baton is not a new cigar, which is part of what makes the score interesting. According to J.C. Newman, the brand was introduced in 1914 as a hand-rolled nickel cigar made with Cuban tobacco at Julius Caeser Newman’s original factory in Cleveland, before disappearing from the market in the 1920s. In 2008, the company revived it as its first Nicaraguan cigar.

Cigar Aficionado’s list item fills in the next chapter. After that 2008 revival as an all-Nicaraguan, wallet-friendly blend, El Baton “was re-blended again in 2022 with stronger fillers and a higher-grade Ecuadoran wrapper.” The magazine says that current blend “certainly seems to deliver well above its pay grade.”

That description matches what J.C. Newman lists on its El Baton product page today: an Ecuadorian Havana wrapper over a Nicaraguan binder and filler, handmade at the company’s PENSA factory in Nicaragua. The company describes the line as a bold, full-bodied cigar with notes of spice, espresso and dark cocoa. The “full-bodied” language is J.C. Newman’s description of the line; Cigar Aficionado rated this particular Belicoso medium-full.

El Baton Belicoso cigars in their box
El Baton Belicosos in a box of the 5-inch by 56-ring size Cigar Aficionado rated. Photo: J.C. Newman Cigar Co.

The Belicoso is one of four regular sizes. J.C. Newman’s site also lists a Robusto (5″ x 54), a Double Toro (6″ x 60) and a Double Torpedo (6 1/4″ x 56). The 92-point score applies to the Belicoso that was tasted for the October 2026 issue, not automatically to every size in the line.

A Strong Issue, and a Busy Month for J.C. Newman

El Baton was not the only familiar name on the list. The same Cigar Aficionado roundup also included the Arturo Fuente Añejo Reserva No. 888 and La Flor Dominicana’s Solis Toro, both at 92 points, alongside higher-scoring cigars such as the Tatuaje Havana VI Almirantes at 94. We recently covered other news from two of those companies, including Fuente’s Añejo River Valley Rare Earth and La Flor Dominicana’s Holiday Lanceros.

It’s been a busy stretch for J.C. Newman itself. In the past week we reported on the company’s redesigned website, its target of early 2027 for the restored Sanchez y Haya building in Ybor City, the U.S. Semiquincentennial Commission’s visit to El Reloj, and the “Hot Stick” cigars it made with the Tampa Bay Lightning for Alex Ovechkin.

The Cigar Guys’ Take

A 92-point score on a cigar that costs $10.40 is the kind of result that gets people’s attention, especially when it comes from a blind tasting. El Baton has been easy to overlook next to J.C. Newman’s better-known lines, and this is a reminder that the 2022 reblend is doing real work.

The score is for one size, the 5 x 56 Belicoso, in one issue. That’s still a strong showing for a cigar J.C. Newman has long positioned as a hearty, everyday Nicaraguan smoke. We’ll be curious to see whether the other sizes get their own moment in a future tasting.

Keep it locked to The Cigar Guys Podcast for more cigar news every week.

Sources: Cigar Aficionado: 13 Extraordinary Smokes That Should Be In Your Humidor (Thomas Pappalardo, Nov. 9, 2026); Cigar Aficionado: El Baton Belicoso rating (October 2026 issue); J.C. Newman Cigar Co. email, “Cigar Aficionado Names El Baton Belicoso One of the ‘Extraordinary Smokes That Should Be In Your Humidor'” (Nov. 19, 2026); J.C. Newman: El Baton product page (accessed Nov. 20, 2026)

FILED UNDERNEWS
Get our posts in your Google Top Stories
Add The Cigar Guys as a preferred source — a one-click Google Search setting, not a subscription — so our cigar news is more likely to show when you search.