The world of cigars is rich with tradition, culture, and, unfortunately, myths. Whether you’re a seasoned cigar aficionado or just starting, you’ve encountered various pieces of advice that may or may not be accurate. In this article, we’ll debunk some of the most common cigar myths, separating fact from fiction to help you confidently enjoy cigars.
Myth 1: The Darker the Cigar, the Stronger the Flavor
False. One of the most pervasive myths in the cigar world is that the darker the cigar, the stronger the flavor. While it’s true that some dark cigars can be strong, the color of the wrapper doesn’t necessarily indicate strength.
- Reality: The darkness of a cigar wrapper (often a Maduro wrapper) comes from the fermentation process, which can make the tobacco sweeter rather than stronger. The strength of a cigar is determined by the blend of the filler tobacco inside, not just the wrapper.
Myth 2: Cigars Should Be Stored in the Refrigerator
False. Some believe that refrigerating cigars will keep them fresh, but this harms the tobacco.
- Reality: Refrigerators are too cold and dry for cigars, which can cause the tobacco to dry out and lose its flavor. Cigars should be stored in a humidor, which maintains the proper humidity level (65-70%) and temperature (around 70°F).
Myth 3: You Should Inhale Cigar Smoke Like Cigarette Smoke
False. Unlike cigarette smoking, cigar smoking is not about inhaling the smoke into your lungs.
- Reality: Cigar smoke is meant to be savored in the mouth to appreciate the complex flavors and aromas. Inhaling cigar smoke can be harsh and overwhelming, especially because cigars typically contain more nicotine than cigarettes.
Myth 4: A High Price Always Means a Better Cigar
False. While price can indicate quality, it’s not a guaranteed measure of how much you’ll enjoy a cigar.
- Reality: The enjoyment of a cigar is subjective, and a more expensive cigar doesn’t always mean a better experience. Factors such as your taste, the blend of tobacco, and the cigar’s construction all contribute to the overall experience. Sometimes, cheaper cigars can offer just as much pleasure as their pricier counterparts.
Myth 5: The Ash Should Be Long and Unbroken for the Best Smoke
Partially True. A long, unbroken ash can indicate a well-constructed cigar, but it’s not a strict requirement for a good smoking experience.
- Reality: While a long ash can be a sign of sound construction, focusing too much on maintaining it can detract from your enjoyment. The most important aspect is that the cigar burns evenly and produces a good draw. If the ash falls off naturally, it’s not a problem.
Myth 6: You Must Finish a Cigar in One Sitting
False. Many believe that once a cigar is lit, it must be finished in one go. However, this is only sometimes true.
- Reality: While enjoying a cigar in one Sitting is ideal, you can relight it later, the same day or the next morning if needed. To do this without affecting the flavor too much, gently blow out the smoke before setting the cigar down and storing it in a cool, dry place. When ready to relight, trim the ash and gently toast the foot before drawing again. Again, this is only good for MAX one full day. Also, expect to taste different flavors than the initial light. Letting the half-lit cigar sit for extended periods will cause the cigar to change its flavor.
Myth 7: Cigars Are Only for Special Occasions
False. While cigars are often associated with celebrations, they can be enjoyed anytime.
- Reality: Many cigar enthusiasts enjoy smoking cigars as part of their daily or weekly routine, not just for special occasions. The idea that cigars are only for weddings, promotions, or other significant events must be clarified. They can be a simple pleasure enjoyed after a meal, leisurely walk, or unwinding after a long day.
Myth 8: Bigger Cigars Are Always Better
False. Some believe larger cigars automatically provide a better experience, but size alone doesn’t determine quality.
- Reality: The cigar size should match the smoker’s preference and the amount of time available to smoke. Larger cigars, like Churchills or Double Coronas, offer longer smoking sessions, while smaller cigars, like Robustos or Petit Coronas, are better for shorter occasions. The best cigar is the one that suits your personal taste and smoking duration.
Myth 9: You Should Always Rotate Cigars in a Humidor
True. Rotating cigars in your humidor can help maintain consistent humidity levels across your collection.
Reality:** Rotating your cigars every few months ensures that those at the bottom or sides of the humidor get the same level of humidity as those at the top. This practice helps prevent uneven aging and ensures that all your cigars are kept in optimal condition.
Conclusion: Separating Fact from Fiction in Cigar Smoking
Cigarette smoking is an art form, but it’s also an experience surrounded by myths and misconceptions. By understanding what’s true and false, you can make more informed choices and enjoy your cigars to the fullest. Knowing the facts helps you appreciate the rich tradition and culture of cigar smoking without being misled by common myths, whether you’re storing, cutting, or simply savoring your cigar.
171. Catelli Cigars Owners: Building a Brand & Lounge from Scratch | The Cigar Guys Podcast – The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 171. Catelli Cigars Owners: Building a Brand & Lounge from Scratch | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 170. PCA 2026 Preview: Sans Pareil CEO & VP on What’s Coming | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 169. Can We Guess These Whiskeys? Blind Barrels Challenge | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 168. What to Expect at PCA 2026 – William Marante Joins Us | The Cigar Guys Podcast
- 167. Joe Perkins on Sans Pareil Cigars & His Career Journey | The Cigar Guys Podcast
